Defend your faith!No duplicates.How well do your beliefs hold up?The ultimate scoreboard of Truth.The #1 argument mining website.Objectifying debates.Defend your faith!No duplicates.How well do your beliefs hold up?The ultimate scoreboard of Truth.The #1 argument mining website.Objectifying debates.
About R3fute: Defend your faith! No duplicates. How well do your beliefs hold up? The ultimate scoreboard of Truth. The #1 argument mining website. Objectifying debates.

No login required! Defend your beliefs now!
Create

Answer in Is Islam true?

⌂ Argument homeLayer 2 of 2
THIS NO ANSWER100%holds up↑ up a layer
  • Yes
  • No
  • Faded: answered, or not hitting
  • Inner ring: its replies · outer: theirs
  • ★ Star

This No answer holds up 100%

No replies yet, so nothing has answered it.

Nothing has answered it yet

When people reply, their replies fill this ring, sized by how hard they hit and how well they hold up. R3fute it below.

Argument hierarchy

You're on layer 2 of 2

Nothing below this yet. Can anyone answer it?

X import

Answer · No

UnansweredA No answer to Is Islam true?

The Quran's alleged guarantee of Hell-Fire to believers in Muhammad conflicts with the path to salvation Islam offers.

  1. 1The Quran says believers in Muhammad are guaranteed Hell-Fire (Quran 19:68–72).
  2. 2If Islam is true, the Quran does not guarantee Hell-Fire to believers in Muhammad.implied

Therefore: Islam is false.

Deductive form
Original wording

Brutal Fact: The Quran says believers in Muhammad are guaranteed Hell-Fire, Quran 19:68-72. https://t.co/JmLjCHPvcc

From a post on X by GodLogic_GL (@GodLogic_GL) · November 19, 2026

R3fute this!

Show where this answer fails: a premise it needs, or its reasoning

← All arguments in Is Islam true?

Create