Defend your faith!No duplicates.How well do your beliefs hold up?The ultimate scoreboard of Truth.The #1 argument mining website.Objectifying debates.Defend your faith!No duplicates.How well do your beliefs hold up?The ultimate scoreboard of Truth.The #1 argument mining website.Objectifying debates.
About R3fute: Defend your faith! No duplicates. How well do your beliefs hold up? The ultimate scoreboard of Truth. The #1 argument mining website. Objectifying debates.

No login required! Defend your beliefs now!
Create

Question

Is Islam true?

Monotheistic Abrahamic religion founded by Muhammad

The shape of the debate

Truth first, then engagement
2 of 2REFUTATIONS STAND2 answers
  • Yes
  • No
  • Faded: answered, or not hitting
  • Inner ring: answers · outer: replies
  • ★ Star
Yes 0%100% No

Share of the weight, not a probability of truth. What counts against a belief system is the refutations still standing.

Which answers still stand?

Point at a segment to see how well that post holds up. The inner ring is the answers; the outer rings are the replies to them, and the replies to those. Open an answer to see its part of the rings up close.

  1. Muhammad's ownership of black slaves and demeaning description of Ethiopians disqualify him as a true prophet, making Islam false.50%
  2. The Quran's alleged guarantee of Hell-Fire to believers in Muhammad conflicts with the path to salvation Islam offers.50%
How the weights work

Truth first. Every post stands until a reply answers it. A reply weakens what it answers by how adequately the AI judged it to answer it, but only as much as that reply still stands against its own replies, and so on down the thread. So a challenge that was itself answered stops counting, and an inadequate or ungraded one doesn't count yet.

Then engagement. An answer's weight is how much it still stands, squared, times up to double for how much discussion it drew compared with the other answers. An answer nobody has challenged keeps full weight; one answered three ways with no reply to any of them keeps almost none; one that has held up under many challenges can weigh twice as much as an untested one.

The count. A belief system stands until it's refuted, so the number in the middle is how many No answers (refutations) still stand out of all that were made. A Yes answer nobody has challenged adds weight but proves nothing; answering the refutations is what brings the count down.

Stars. The star argument is the heaviest answer that still stands, when it clearly leads; each layer of replies has its own star reply. These weights are an experiment, not a verdict on a belief system.

What this asks

Whether Islam is true, with Islam meaning what Wikipedia means by it: Monotheistic Abrahamic religion founded by Muhammad.

Wikipedia ↗

A tradition's name means its mainstream (Islam is Sunni Islam); a branch is a question of its own.

Posts within Islam

What Islam's own law or teaching holds, argued from its own sources.

+ Ask a question within Islam

It's argued from Islam's own sources. An admin approves new questions before they're listed.

Still standing

Refutations (No)
2 of 2
Arguments for (Yes)
0 of 0

Islam stands until it's refuted, so what counts against it is the refutations still standing. An answer stands until a reply that still stands itself answers it adequately (AI grades every reply, down the thread). A count of arguments, not a verdict.

Videos

No video's arguments are in this question yet.

Create