About
A Wikipedia of arguments, one yes/no question per belief system.
Is Islam true? Is Shia Islam true? Is atheism true? R3fute collects the strongest answers under Yes and No, threads every reply to them, and keeps track of which answers still stand.
Mission
The same debates happen again and again, and good arguments disappear into comment threads. R3fute turns them into one lasting, connected record: every argument about a belief system in one place, each with its replies, so anyone can see where a debate actually stands and add something new instead of repeating what's been said.
It starts with religious debate, between faiths and within them, and is built to grow into philosophy, politics, and other contested subjects. Examples on the site are there to be argued over; they aren't R3fute's conclusions, and no verdict here is a ruling on anyone's faith.
Truth by elimination
R3fute doesn't try to prove beliefs true. Every position is the default until it's refuted: it stands open to attack, and the ones still standing after every attack are the candidates for truth. The last man standing.
The burden is on the argument. The answer a thread starts from succeeds only if every premise it needs is established and its reasoning is valid. A reply against it doesn't have to prove its own side: showing that one premise it needs is unsupported, or that its reasoning fails, defeats it. A reply defending it has to make that premise good again; saying it a second time isn't enough.
So an answer stands until a reply defeats it, whichever side it's on. A belief system stands the same way, so its question leads with the count that matters: how many refutations of it (No answers) still stand. A Yes answer nobody has challenged proves nothing. Every grade and AI opinion on the site follows this rule.
How it's organized
- Questions
- One per belief system, religious or political: Is Islam true?, Is Shia Islam true?, Is Zionism true?. Terms mean what Wikipedia means by them, and each question's side panel quotes Wikipedia's description. A tradition's name means its mainstream (Islam is Sunni Islam; Christianity is mainstream Nicene Christianity), and a branch is a question of its own. There are no lists of core beliefs: an answer argues about the belief system as Wikipedia describes it. A new question waits for an admin's approval before it's listed; until then it opens by its link. All of them are under Debates.
- Answers
- Arguments under Yes or No: that the belief system is true, or that it's false. An answer goes to the most specific belief system its reasoning bears on: one against the twelve Imams, posted on Is Islam true?, moves to Is Shia Islam true? as a No (the question is added if it isn't here yet). An answer that repeats one already here is pointed to it instead (no duplicates).
- Posts within
- Yes/no questions on what a belief system's own law or teaching holds, like “Is shrimp halal?” within Is Islam true?. They're argued from that belief system's own sources, whose premises are granted there, and are listed under its question. Anyone can ask one from Create or the belief system's page.
- Replies
- Every answer starts a thread. A reply argues the other side from the post it answers (a reply to a No answer argues Yes), however deep the thread goes, and each has its own page.
- Videos
- A debate posted from YouTube, audio, or a transcript (posting videos is for Pro members). AI pulls the transcript, finds every argument made in it and when, threads the replies, and shows them on a timeline below the player. Each argument is then placed in the question it answers, as a Yes or No answer or at the point in a thread it answers, so one video can add to several questions. A question's side panel lists the videos its arguments came from: choose one to see that question's Yes and No for that video's arguments alone. Videos also live in the video library.
- Star argument
- On a question, the heaviest answer that still stands (below), and in every thread, the strongest reply at each layer. In a video, the one or two decisive moments: the argument that settled the exchange, or the reply that defeated it, shown right under the video's title with its time.
- X posts
- Paste a link to a post on X into Create: AI reads the argument in it and posts it as an answer or reply where it belongs, crediting its author and linking back to the original. The same post pasted again opens the existing one, and one that repeats a post already here is added to it as another place it was made.
How a thread works
- Yes and No
- Blue is Yes, red is No. An answer takes one side, and every reply takes the other side from the post it replies to. Any of them can trend.
- R3fute!
- Every post has a R3fute button for replying to it, colored by the side the reply takes.
- Argument map
- Every answer and reply opens on its part of the question's rings, expanded: the post in the centre, its replies around it, and theirs beyond, sized and faded by how well each holds up, with that layer's star reply. A segment opens that reply's map; the centre goes back up a layer; a small ring shows where the thread sits in the whole question.
- Argument hierarchy
- The whole debate top down, a layer per row: the question, its answers, the replies to each, and so on. The post you're on sits in the middle of its layer with a line up to what it answers and lines down to its replies, and the page says which layer you're on. Press a box to center it; “Argument home” jumps back to your place.
- Deductive form
- Every argument is restated as numbered premises and a conclusion that follows from them. Assumptions the author implied but didn't state are marked IMPLIED. The author's own wording is one click away, and anyone can report a form that misrepresents it. An answer concludes that the belief system is true or false; when it argues about something narrower (a doctrine, a text), the step from that to the belief system is stated as an implied premise, so a reply can take it on.
- Answer what was said
- A reply has to take on the post it answers: each premise that answers part of it is marked with a highlighted (↩ P2) pointing back to the premise it answers. A competing argument that leaves the reasoning untouched only starts a second thread, so it isn't posted as a reply: post it as an answer of its own.
- One point per post
- Each post makes one argument, so it can be answered on its own. A post that makes several is offered a split.
- When a post isn't posted
- You're told why, and your text stays in the box: it argues about no belief system's truth, it doesn't take on the post it answers (it says which premise to address), it repeats a post that's already here (it shows that post and asks what's different), it makes several separate points (it offers to split them), or its reasoning can't be followed (it asks what you mean).
What the verdicts mean
Does an answer still stand?
- Unanswered
- No one has replied to it yet, so it stands.
- Holding up
- It has been challenged, but no reply that still stands answers it adequately. It stands.
- Awaiting grade
- Someone replied, and AI hasn't graded the reply yet. It stands until a reply is graded adequate.
- Refuted
- A reply that still stands answers it adequately, so it no longer stands.
Standing is worked out down the whole thread. A reply weakens what it answers by how adequately the AI judged it to answer it, but only as much as that reply still stands against its own replies, and so on: a challenge that was itself answered stops counting. A belief system's question counts its refutations still standing, then the Yes answers still standing. An unanswered answer stands because the burden is on whoever replies: it was posted as a valid argument with every premise stated, and until a reply shows one of those premises unsupported or false, nothing has answered it.
The shape of the debate, and star arguments
A question's chart sizes each answer by its weight: truth first, then engagement. An answer's truth is how much it still stands; its weight is that, squared, times up to double for how much discussion it drew compared with the other answers. So an answer nobody has challenged keeps full weight, one answered three ways with no reply to any of them keeps almost none, and one that has held up under many challenges can weigh twice as much as an untested one. A reply's truth is how hard it still hits what it answers. The heaviest answer that still stands is the star argument, and each layer of replies has its own star reply. The weights are an experiment, not a verdict on a belief system.
Does a reply answer what it replies to?
AI grades every reply, at any depth, against the post it replies to and nothing said afterwards. A reply against the thread's answer is adequate when it shows that a premise the post needs is false or unsupported, or that its reasoning doesn't follow. A reply defending the thread's answer is adequate when it makes good what the challenge took away. It's inadequate when it misses the point, only restates its own side, denies a premise without dealing with the support given for it, attacks the person, or gives up a belief the belief system holds while arguing Yes for it. The meter shows how well it answers. What comes later never changes the grade: a reply to it is graded in turn, and counts through standing. In lists, a reply shows one verdict: Adequate reply, Inadequate reply, Awaiting grade, or Refuted when it answered its post and was then refuted itself.
Example
AI grade on a −100 to +100 scale; above zero is adequate.
AI:It engages the answer's key premise and shows where it fails.
Disagree with the AI?
Every AI opinion has Ask why and It's wrong: here's why. Ask, and the AI explains which attacks it judged to stand or fail. Object, and it states your point at its strongest, checks it against the post (and the video, with times), and re-judges. It changes its opinion only when your reasoning changes the result, never because of pressure. If you still think it's wrong, you can send it to the admins, and every exchange is kept.
Does an argument hold up?
Anyone can grade an argument Sound or Not sound: whether the reasoning works, not whether you agree with it. The bar shows people's grades. An answer gets no AI opinion of its own: it's tested only by its replies, which the AI grades. Videos also have a community opinion bar for which side people take (one vote per network) and an AI opinion bar for which side the arguments favor.
None of these is a verdict on a belief system or a person. They show where the arguments posted here currently stand, and they change as people post.
Labels
- [UNVERIFIED]Unverified
- New and not yet checked by a moderator.
- [VERIFIED]Verified
- A moderator checked it.
- PROPro
- A Pro member, who can post videos and audio.
Keeping it fair
- No repeats
- A post that looks like one already here asks its author what's different, and a moderator reviews it, so each argument appears once and gathers all its replies.
- Reports
- Anything can be reported, with “Something else” when no reason fits. Admins review reports, and AI can help fix them, but only in ways that can be undone and are recorded: moving an answer to the question it belongs in, rewriting a deductive form, or taking spam and abuse down.
- Edit history
- Every edit keeps the wording it replaced. A post that was edited shows “Edited · history” with each earlier version, when it changed, and who changed it.
- Trending
- Answers, replies, and videos ranked by activity in the last week. The questions themselves are listed under Debates.
- Rules
- Argue the point, not the person. See the Content Guidelines.
You on R3fute
- No account needed to post
- You can post and vote right away without an account; your post goes up first. Then you can keep ownership of your posts with a passkey (Face ID, Touch ID, your phone) or a code you choose, or sign in. Without one of those, clearing your browser's cookies loses your posts for good.
- Reclaiming your posts
- Your code (or passkey) works on any of your posts: “Is this yours? Reclaim it” brings back everything you posted from that browser. Once your posts belong to an account, no code can claim them.
- Signing in
- With X, an email or text code (or the link in the email), or a passkey (Face ID, Touch ID, Windows Hello, or your phone). They aren't separate accounts: add all of them to one account in Settings, and use whichever you like. You can make an account with just a passkey.
- Pro
- Pro members post debate videos and audio, and show a gold PRO tag by their name. A referral code can give a free first month.
- Chat is for members
- Anyone can read the Everyone room; chatting there, in the members room, and in private chats needs an account.
- Anonymous by default
- Everyone appears as a cover name like “Refuter 1234” until they choose to show their username. You can swap your cover name for a new random one in Edit profile; your past posts follow it.
- Deleting your post
- You can delete your own posts. A deleted post stays up so the debate around it still makes sense, marked “Deleted by its author”, with your name removed. It keeps its rating, still counts toward its question's standing answers, can still be refuted, and links to any newer versions of it.
- Private chat
- Members can message the author of any answer or reply privately; only the two of you (and moderators) can read it.
- Support
- Lost access, a problem with a post, or anything else: the Support link at the bottom of every page. We decide each one case by case.
- Notifications
- The bell shows replies to your posts, messages, mentions, and grades of your replies. You can also get them by email or text, from account settings.